OPINION

CHANDRAYAAN 2 : A close Miss but a Historic experience

Just a few days to this incident . We attempted to make History by launching CHANDRAYAAN 2 the Follow up mission to CHANDRAYAAN 1 (2008) . The mission would have accomplished when it’s Lander (VIKRAM LANDER) would have landed safely and completely on moon at around 70°C . We came so agonisingly close but it didn’t happen ….. Goddamit . If it would have happened we would have become only the 4th country in the world to achieve this feat (SOVIET UNION , US and RUSSIA) Let’s look at this whole Journey briefly and discuss this issue .

It was launched on 22 July by GEOSYNCHRONOUS Satellite launch vehicle Mark – III (GSLV MK III) . It comprised of three main parts – the ORBITER , the VIKRAM LANDER and the ROVER PRAGYAN . The most important , Lander was named on VIKRAM SARABHAI the father scientist of indian space programme . The Rover derives it’s name from SANSKRIT (PRAGYAN) meaning Wisdom , it has the special feature of leveraging solar energy for it’s functioning . First one had to escape Earth’s gravity ensuring going at the right speed , making 5 Complex Manoeuvres to gain Momentum before going far enough to be caught up by Moon . Then we had to slowly decrease the speed to land perfectly .

Now when it placed itself completely on MOON’s Orbit. The Lander tried to make a soft landing on Moon , which was the most complex job of all and that’s what mattered the most and where it missed it . Firstly it cleared ROUGH BREAKING PHASE swooping down it’s distance from moon and dropping down it’s Velocity . Now in the FINE BREAKING PHASE it had to re orient itself and look for pictures of slopes and hazards . Just in the final 2 minutes when it was just 2.1 km away from moon it lost the contact . The green lines on screen showed it has strayed from it’s path . What was it ? Did the Thrusters overperform ? Did it lose altitude and didn’t recover ? Whatever it was , what mattered was that we couldn’t land on Moon . Just like the CHANDRAYAAN the hopes and expectations of 1.3 Billions crashed .

The most heartbreaking scene was ISRO Chairman K SIVAN breaking down after ISRO failed to regain contact . Such a senior person who has achieved so many things in life , ISRO has achieved so much under him . But what made him cry was the realisation that the hearts of 1.3 billion people are broken . It was a very remarkable thing by our PM to hug him , console him and assure him that the whole Nation stands with ISRO . That is a quality of a true leader , whether you applause your team on victory or not but make sure to console them on a Loss .

CHANDRAYAAN 1 whose follow up mission this one is was launched in 2008 and was Operational for 312 days . It discovered traces of water on Moon and state like ice in the north polar region . It’s other achievements were detection of Magnesium , Silicon , Aluminium and global imaging of moon . But more information was needed regarding how water is distributed exactly on the surface . One remarkable point about this Mission was ; we tried to land on the South pole region which no other country has tried on their first attempt (eveyone landed on North Pole only) . CHINA’S chang’e 4 became the first ever spacecraft to land on far side on the Moon . We chose south pole because :

  • It is larger in surface area and there is a high possibility of finding Water .
  • This side always remains in shadow as only low angle of sunlight strikes it .
  • South pole region is extremely cold and contains CRATERS that are cold traps and contain Fossil record of solar system as well .

These factors made south pole worth investing .

But so tough were the challenges , such as :

  • Lunar terrain is Rocky and Moon’s gravity is 17% that of Earth .
  • Earth rotates at 400,000 km/h while Moon at 4,000 km/h . Coming out if one and going into another is not a Joke .
  • Moon Dust rises and falls can disable sensitive instruments on a lander specially those which were not a part of the previous mission .

The scientists are trying to regain connection with the lander which has crashed and is tilted on Moon but chances are at it’s minimal . But it will continue to Orbit around Moon for next year sending the images by scanning and mapping the surface . We have heard about the end of the Rover and Lander but the ORBITER gliding 100km above the Moon still bears the CHANDRAYAAN Torch and INDIAN Flag . It will be beaming us back Pictures from there . The images may help us find out what went wrong , where we missed which may turn out very useful for future Planetary missions .

70 students from different schools across India were selected through a test conducted by ISRO . They were getting the golden opportunity to witness India’s landing on Moon along with our honourable Prime Minister . First time in my memory did it happened that people were sticking to their TV Sets at 1:30 am at Night . It feels very proud but if you would ask me ; personally I think that these kind of scientific missions should be done with as less as tantrums possible . I am not saying BURI NAZAR or something like that but it’s not a Cricket match going on here where the whole country is watching late till night and lucky cricket fans are sitting in the Star Sports studio . Publicising it that much brings us straightaway in the eyes of the world which we should avoid until we have done the Job .

Whatever be the case now it’s all over but should we call the Mission a Failure ? I don’t think so , in my opinion it will be both unfair and wrong to call it so . Coming so close of such a tedious mission can , or we can say should be called a Success which should be celebrated by all of us . According to ISRO scientists also it’s Technically a Success and has achieved 90% of it’s targets perfectly . Moon is 3,84,400 kms away from us and we failed at 2.1 km that is 0.0005463% of margin . Even this failure is a foundation for new beginnings .
Even this failure has a taste of success in it .
Kudos to our Scientists and ISRO . Proud of you .

Average people have wishes and prayers while the confident ones have targets and missions . For a dream to come true you have to first dream . We learnt an important lesson that life never goes smoothly but still we should aim high , try hard and still have the courage to face Failure also . ISRO holds many records such as Cheapest mission to Mars , getting to Mars on first attempt , launching 104 satellites in a single go . Even this Mission was way cheaper than rest made by the world . Even USA failed 12 times , CHINA and RUSSIA 8 and 6 times respectively ; so it’s a not the case that just because we are very successful unit we don’t have the permission to Fail sometimes anymore . Our RESULT does not decide our success or failure but our EFFORT does ; which was at it’s fullest . It’s not a failure but a step back to make it better and bigger .

This was not the last mission nor the last try we have made going on to Moon . Okay , we lost this time but we will all come together and will win eventually by reaching out on the Moon ; it’s the time to take in account all shortcomings and faults and prepare for the next mission . We missed AKSHAY KUMAR’s next movie script this time , but we all can hope that he gets his script and we all our proud moment with CHANDRAYAAN 3 .

“TU CHAAND HAI NAKHRE TO DIKHAEGA ….. YE BHARAT TERA AASHIQ HAI LAUT KAR AAYEGA … !!!!!

“Sometimes we don’t land or arrive the destination we want to . The important thing is that we took off and had the belief that we can . Our current situation is not and never our final destination . It always comes with time and belief” … !!!!!

JAI HIND

ARUNESH SINHA

Don’t miss my posts!

We don’t spam!

Arunesh
About author

Hello, everyone...I am Arunesh. I am a journalist by profession and blogger by passion. I am here to present my opinions and analysis on some of the most moving stories in the world, along with some interesting pieces on movies, cricket and some original short story content.  Watch out this space for some of the great writings of the time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *